This is not a response to all teachers, but it is a response to many.
You think that you are in charge of your classrooms. That is false. The educational system does not exist for or because of the teachers. The inmates are already running the asylum - the moment they start to realize it, which is the kind of epiphany projects like VOST2011 can bring, you have an issue. Right now your notion that you are in power is derived entirely from an outdated, suppressive system of grades (rhetoric ftw). Eliminate the strong-arm power of the grade, and you eliminate any illusion of power the instructor has. This doesn't have to be done by overthrowing traditional grading systems and installing a new educational pedagogy (although preferable); it is just as effectively done by promoting such apathy in students that they no longer care what grades they get. Students become masters not at achieving, but at doing just enough to get by, whether they are trying to get by with an A, B, or C. Grading is not a system of reward, it's a system of punishment based entirely on arbitrary and variable expectations of one instructor. Your view of the classroom suppresses student desires to learn outside of what you feed them for exams. You are not in power, and the illusion that you are is ultimately nothing by detrimental.
You tell us to adapt to your systems, but should I question your methods or the reasons you bind me within them, I am seen not as a thinker, but as a disrespectful child. The classroom is used not only to train the psyche of the students, but the psyche of the professor as well. I am trained to think I have no power, and you are trained to believe you have nothing but. We're both wrong. And because we're both wrong, unless there is some acknowledgment that our roles are merely constructs of the system rather than educational necessities, the possibility for change, innovation, is gone. What does it even mean to adapt? If I dutifully transcribe your lectures with my classical #2 pencil and lined notebook paper, have I done my job as a student? If I carefully craft my papers to make sure they favor your personal opinions, am I being a good student? How much dissent am I allowed, and in what ways do I get to express it? Maybe you should just put this on your syllabus for me. Make sure you give a syllabus quiz, or else I won't read it.
You tell us to adapt to your systems, but should I question your methods or the reasons you bind me within them, I am seen not as a thinker, but as a disrespectful child. The classroom is used not only to train the psyche of the students, but the psyche of the professor as well. I am trained to think I have no power, and you are trained to believe you have nothing but. We're both wrong. And because we're both wrong, unless there is some acknowledgment that our roles are merely constructs of the system rather than educational necessities, the possibility for change, innovation, is gone. What does it even mean to adapt? If I dutifully transcribe your lectures with my classical #2 pencil and lined notebook paper, have I done my job as a student? If I carefully craft my papers to make sure they favor your personal opinions, am I being a good student? How much dissent am I allowed, and in what ways do I get to express it? Maybe you should just put this on your syllabus for me. Make sure you give a syllabus quiz, or else I won't read it.
The present world does not speak well for our system of education. Education should not be conceived of as a dominant-subordinate relationship, but as one of artist-apprentice, or guide-explorer, relationships that are mutually beneficial. Teachers should be sad to see students leave.
The problem with the standard classroom is this: it assumes a fixed point of view on the behalf of both the student and the teacher. You stand up front and talk at me (at, not to). I sit in back and listen for you (for, not to). This inscribes the idea that we each stand in a certain immobile social location. But, as I quoted McLuhan, "It's impossible to have a point of view in the electric age and have any meaning at all." Mediation is a fact of modern life, and by opening up a world of alternative perspectives, it has made the idea of a singular point of view all but meaningless. What is learned in the undergrad classroom is not what translates to the world outside of that classroom, not even in academia. When I publish research as a postdoc, it will not receive a letter grade. It will be criticized and agreed with. Responses and counter-responses will be written. Rather than being assumed to be fixed, points of view will be varied, shifting, and yet integrated.
I've seen a lot of teachers today blaming student distraction on technology. No. Technology enables us to express our distraction, but it does not cause our distraction. If I am in a class that excites me and interests me, my technology is used for nothing but facilitating my learning in that class. If I am in a class that is dull and non-communicative, I am not going to pay more attention because you take my laptop away - in fact, personal anecdotes say I become even more distracted because absent any way to stimulate my brain for an hour, I shut down entirely.
If students are failing to learn, it is not entirely the teacher's fault - that is not the argument. I blame the students too. There's a reason I dislike most group projects, and that reason is the group members. It is and should be, however, the teacher's concern if students are not learning. Why are you a teacher if not to spread your knowledge? And if you are failing to do this in a way that is effective for many of your students, doesn't that upset you? Doesn't it worry you? It should.
Great stuff.
ReplyDeleteI was in an ethics class...ETHICS...class this morning, a student asked, "Is that right?" Ethics? Right? This is the class that Joseph and I keep mentioning, rooted deeply in philosophy. Philosophy does not have a right and wrong. This class explores the extremes, blacks and whites, in pursuit of the gray that is real life. Yet a student has been brainwashed, flattened, enough to ask if her philosophy was "right." God help us all.
I don't generally like group projects either! They always seem like royal opportunity to either slack or do all the work. There was no collaboration. There was no synergy. We need the freedom to be individual and creative, yet we also need the beauty that comes with different perspectives and beliefs. (Insert emotional yelp at this point.)